Scoreclever Editorial Analysis | ea.scoreclever.com
The Hindu Editorial • April 07, 2026 • Read Original
Arrest the grief: On illegal sand mining in central India
Livelihood issues are at the heart of illegal sand mining in central India
Scoreclever
Win Exams Cleverly
Analysis of editorial from The Hindu newspaper on April 07, 2026
Arrest the grief: On illegal sand mining in central India
Livelihood issues are at the heart of illegal sand mining in central India
Sand MiningNational Chambal Gharial SanctuarySupreme CourtGharial ConservationEnvironmental Governance
Sentences
Sentence 1 of 20
Sentence 1 of 20
The National Chambal Gharial Sanctuary in central India protects a lotic ecosystem across an area straddling three States.
Phrase Breakdown
Subject
The National Chambal Gharial Sanctuary in central India
A large nature park in the middle of India made specifically to save a type of crocodile called the Gharial
Verb
protects
Keeps safe from harm or damage
Object
a lotic ecosystem
A nature system that exists in moving water, like a river
Adjunct
across an area straddling three States
In a place that reaches into and connects three different Indian states (Rajasthan, MP, and UP)
Sentence 2 of 20
Its existence is crucial for the critically endangered gharial, the red-crowned roofed turtle and the endangered Ganges river dolphin.
Phrase Breakdown
Subject
Its existence
The fact that this sanctuary is there
Verb
is
Shows the state of being
Complement
crucial for the critically endangered gharial, the red-crowned roofed turtle and the endangered Ganges river dolphin
Very important for three rare animals that are in danger of disappearing forever
Sentence 3 of 20
All three species depend on sand to survive, especially the river’s sandbars and sandbanks.
Phrase Breakdown
Subject
All three species
The gharial, the turtle, and the dolphin mentioned before
Verb
depend
Need something to live
Object
on sand
On the tiny pieces of rock found in rivers
Adjunct
to survive
In order to stay alive
Adjunct
especially the river’s sandbars and sandbanks
Particularly the heaps of sand formed inside or along the sides of the river
Sentence 4 of 20
Yet, organised crime and state paralysis have been stealing away just that sand, prompting the Supreme Court of India to call the local sand-mining mafia “modern dacoits”.
Phrase Breakdown
Adjunct
Yet
But despite these facts
Subject
organised crime and state paralysis
Illegal groups working together and the government’s inability to stop them
Verb
have been stealing away
Have been taking something illegally for a long time
Object
just that sand
The exact same sand needed by the animals
Adjunct
prompting the Supreme Court of India to call the local sand-mining mafia “modern dacoits”
Which made the highest court in India describe these illegal sand miners as today’s version of violent bandits
Sentence 5 of 20
The mafia erupted to meet the demand for sand during North India’s construction boom, and has been able to exploit gaps in jurisdiction among the three States — Rajasthan, Madhya Pradesh, and Uttar Pradesh — despite the Court and the National Green Tribunal (NGT) banning the activity.
Phrase Breakdown
Subject
The mafia
The illegal group controlling the sand business
Verb
erupted
Started suddenly and strongly
Adjunct
to meet the demand for sand during North India’s construction boom
Because many buildings were being made in North India and they needed a lot of sand
Verb
has been able to exploit
Has been successfully using a weakness for its own benefit
Object
gaps in jurisdiction among the three States — Rajasthan, Madhya Pradesh, and Uttar Pradesh —
Weaknesses in how laws are applied because the area belongs to three different states
Adjunct
despite the Court and the National Green Tribunal (NGT) banning the activity
Even though top legal offices ordered them to stop
Sentence 6 of 20
State governments have also abetted this ploy by passing the buck on acting against the mafia.
Phrase Breakdown
Subject
State governments
The governments of Rajasthan, Madhya Pradesh, and Uttar Pradesh
Verb
have also abetted
Have helped or encouraged someone to do something wrong
Object
this ploy
This clever plan or trick to continue illegal mining
Adjunct
by passing the buck on acting against the mafia
By avoiding their responsibility and saying it’s the other state’s job to stop the criminals
Sentence 7 of 20
Between 2017 and 2024, tractor trolleys laden with illegally mined sand mowed down forest guards and police officers while miners also shot at police during raids.
Phrase Breakdown
Subject
tractor trolleys laden with illegally mined sand
Farm vehicles carrying stolen sand that was taken without permission
Verb
mowed down
Ran over someone with a vehicle, usually killing or injuring them
Object
forest guards and police officers
The government workers responsible for protecting the nature and enforcing law
Adjunct
Between 2017 and 2024
During these seven years
Adjunct
while miners also shot at police during raids
At the same time, the illegal sand workers fired guns at the police when they came to stop them
Sentence 8 of 20
They have built roads into the riverbed that bypass checkpoints, and set up an extensive network of informers to track the movement of patrols.
Phrase Breakdown
Subject
They
The sand mining mafia
Verb
have built
Have constructed something
Object
roads into the riverbed that bypass checkpoints
Secret paths in the dry parts of the river that go around the places where police wait
Verb
set up
Established or organized a system
Object
an extensive network of informers to track the movement of patrols
A large group of people who secretly give information about the police’s location
Sentence 9 of 20
The state machinery is compromised, since illegal sand mining is a major source of fund for local political groups.
Phrase Breakdown
Subject
The state machinery
The officials and departments that make the government’s rules work
Verb
is
Exists in a certain state
Complement
compromised
No longer working honestly because of bribes or or pressure
Adjunct
since illegal sand mining is a major source of fund for local political groups
Because the local politicians get a lot of money from this illegal work
Sentence 10 of 20
As a result, the mafia operates with impunity, leading to the depletion of sand reserves and the destruction of the Chambal sanctuary.
Phrase Breakdown
Adjunct
As a result
Because of the things mentioned before
Subject
the mafia
The illegal sand mining group
Verb
operates
Works or carries out activities
Adjunct
with impunity
Doing something wrong without being punished
Adjunct
leading to the depletion of sand reserves and the destruction of the Chambal sanctuary
Causing the sand to disappear and damaging the protected natural area
Sentence 11 of 20
The illegal activity is so pervasive that it has drawn the attention of the Supreme Court, which oversees the Central Empowered Committee (CEC).
Phrase Breakdown
Subject
The illegal activity
The work of taking sand without permission
Verb
is
Exists
Complement
so pervasive
Spreading everywhere and hard to stop
Adjunct
that it has drawn the attention of the Supreme Court, which oversees the Central Empowered Committee (CEC)
Because it is so common, the highest court in India is now watching it and managing a special group called the CEC
Sentence 12 of 20
Yet, the three States of Rajasthan, Madhya Pradesh, and Uttar Pradesh have failed to cooperate, as they differ on the best way to handle the mafia.
Phrase Breakdown
Adjunct
Yet
But despite the Court’s watching
Subject
the three States of Rajasthan, Madhya Pradesh, and Uttar Pradesh
The state governments involved in the Chambal area
Verb
have failed to cooperate
Have not worked together or helped each other
Adjunct
as they differ on the best way to handle the mafia
Because they have different ideas about how to stop the illegal groups
Sentence 13 of 20
A recent CEC report on illegal mining in the sanctuary notes that Madhya Pradesh wants the Court to de-notify a 292-hectare area of the sanctuary, arguing it has no aquatic life and is not a suitable habitat for the three species anymore.
Phrase Breakdown
Subject
A recent CEC report on illegal mining in the sanctuary
A new official document from the Central Empowered Committee about protected land theft
Verb
notes
States or mentions certain information
Object
that Madhya Pradesh wants the Court to de-notify a 292-hectare area of the sanctuary, arguing it has no aquatic life and is not a suitable habitat for the three species anymore
Information that the state government is asking to take away protected status from some land because they say animals don’t live there now
Sentence 14 of 20
In return, Madhya Pradesh is offering to add 21,298 hectares of land in the districts of Sheopur and Morena to the sanctuary.
Phrase Breakdown
Adjunct
In return
As a payment or compensation for what they asked for
Subject
Madhya Pradesh
The government of Madhya Pradesh state
Verb
is offering
Is suggesting or promising to give something
Object
to add 21,298 hectares of land in the districts of Sheopur and Morena to the sanctuary
Proposal to give a much larger piece of land in two districts to make it part of the protected area
Sentence 15 of 20
However, this is not a solution as it will only legitimize the mafia’s control over the 292-hectare area, while the new land might not be as suitable for the gharials and dolphins.
Phrase Breakdown
Adjunct
However
But on the other hand
Subject
this
The idea of swapping land mentioned before
Verb
is not
Fails to be
Complement
a solution
A way to fix the problem
Adjunct
as it will only legitimize the mafia’s control over the 292-hectare area, while the new land might not be as suitable for the gharials and dolphins
Because it makes the mafia’s theft legal in one place and the new land might not be good for the river animals to live in
Sentence 16 of 20
Instead of such compromises, the Supreme Court has rightly ordered all three States to coordinate their efforts to protect the sanctuary.
Phrase Breakdown
Adjunct
Instead of such compromises
Rather than doing the deals mentioned before
Subject
the Supreme Court
The highest court in India
Verb
has rightly ordered
Has correctly given a command
Object
all three States
The state governments of MP, Rajasthan, and UP
Adjunct
to coordinate their efforts to protect the sanctuary
To work together properly to keep the animals and the river safe
Sentence 17 of 20
This involves sharing information, conducting joint patrols, and establishing a unified task force to combat the sand-mining mafia across borders.
Phrase Breakdown
Subject
This
The coordination plan ordered by the Court
Verb
involves
Needs or includes
Object
sharing information, conducting joint patrols, and establishing a unified task force to combat the sand-mining mafia across borders
The list of things to do: tell each other what they know, have police from different states work together, and make a special team to fight the criminals everywhere
Sentence 18 of 20
Furthermore, the States should implement technology-driven solutions, such as satellite monitoring and drone surveillance, to detect and deter illegal activities in real-time.
Phrase Breakdown
Adjunct
Furthermore
In addition to the team-work
Subject
the States
The state governments
Verb
should implement
Ought to put a plan or tool into use
Object
technology-driven solutions, such as satellite monitoring and drone surveillance,
Finding ways to use machines like cameras and satellites to fix the problem
Adjunct
to detect and deter illegal activities in real-time
To find and stop the theft exactly when it is happening
Sentence 19 of 20
Only through such decisive and cooperative action can the Chambal sanctuary be saved from the clutches of the sand mafia.
Phrase Breakdown
Adjunct
Only through such decisive and cooperative action
The only way is to work together with strong and clear plans
Subject
the Chambal sanctuary
The protected natural area around the river
Verb
can be saved
Is possible to protect or rescue
Adjunct
from the clutches of the sand mafia
Out of the control of the dangerous criminals who steal sand
Sentence 20 of 20
The time for passing the buck is over; it is time for the States to act as one to preserve the country’s natural heritage.
Phrase Breakdown
Subject
The time for passing the buck
The past period where people avoided blame by blaming others
Verb
is
Represents a state
Complement
over
Finished or ended
Subject
it
The current situation
Verb
is
Exists
Complement
time for the States to act as one to preserve the country’s natural heritage
The moment when state governments must work together to save nature
Reading Comprehension
Practice questions based on this editorial
Reading Comprehension - Illegal Sand Mining
Practice reading comprehension questions based on the editorial about the ecological and socio-economic challenges of illegal sand mining in the National Chambal Gharial Sanctuary.
About Scoreclever
Your Complete Learning Ecosystem
Scoreclever helps you master Current Affairs, English Language, and General Awareness for all Banking, SSC, Railway, and Defence exams. The Scoreclever app has innovative learning techniques that make memorization and revision effortless.
Explore Scoreclever